Skip to content

Security review: a Slack app from one click (issue-464) ​

  • Mechanism: the-loop checklist (reference/security.md), checked against the diff.
  • Outcome: pass.
  • Findings: none.
    • Input: the app name is the only operator input. Control characters, an empty name, a name over 35 characters and a name with no letter or digit are refused before anything is built or written (tested). It reaches the output only through json.dumps, yaml.safe_dump and quote(safe=""), and only into the two name fields.
    • Network and credentials: none. The verb opens no socket and reads no token. The link is opened by the operator's browser, and Slack's own dialog confirms the workspace and scopes before creating anything.
    • File writes: one file, at the path the operator passes or beside the resolved CLI config. Written atomically. A file the command cannot read as a manifest is never overwritten without --name. The file holds no secret.
    • Scope drift: regeneration builds every key except the name from the packaged manifest, so a tampered kept file cannot carry a scope through an upgrade (tested with an added admin scope).
    • Tokens in the conversation: /the-loop:init now says outright never to ask for a token in the chat. Tokens go to the environment or env.file, and the preflight reports presence only.
    • Permissions: the shipped scopes and events are unchanged.
  • Risk tier: 3 (a CLI option that writes one local file, plus walkthrough text; no sensitive path touched). That is below the tier-4 threshold for a named human security sign-off. The PR approval is the human gate.

Released under the MIT License.