Critic review: show the configured remote agents to the model
The
critic-reviewnode's proof. Policy (the-loop critic policy):criticReviewCount: 1, stop on no new findings, escalate on a repeated finding. Critic:codex(harnesscodex, modelgpt-6.1-sol), run locally withthe-loop critic run codex --prompt-file … --work-item issue-34.
Review cycles
| Round | Reviewer | Outcome | Findings → disposition | Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 (attempt 1) | [codex/gpt-6.1-sol] | unavailable: timed out at the critic's 900 s limit, no output | none. Does not count as a round | — |
1 (attempt 2, --timeout 1800) | [codex/gpt-6.1-sol] | new findings (86 s) | C1: an operator-configured id = "" let spawn_subtask(agent="") through, and the workflow ran it locally → will-fix, fixed in 71c1545. C2: deduplication merged truncation records of different skills, so R4.2's one warning per truncated field was lost → will-fix, fixed in 433f694 (fields named skills[i].name / skills[i].description) | comment |
The cap is one round, so the loop stops here. Neither finding repeats a self-review finding (F1, F2). Both fixes are red→green.
Critic on R5–R7 (after PR review)
| Round | Critic | Outcome | Findings → disposition |
|---|---|---|---|
2 (attempt 1, --timeout 1800) | [codex/gpt-6.1-sol] | unavailable: no output at the 1,800 s limit, 0 tokens | none. Does not count as a round |
2 (attempt 2, --timeout 2400, scope narrowed to executor.py, activities.py, workflows.py, models.py) | [codex/gpt-6.1-sol] | unavailable: no output at the 2,400 s limit, 0 tokens | none. Does not count as a round |
Both attempts used no tokens: the critic did not start, so neither is a review that ran long. The critic round on R5–R7 is therefore missing. The self-review (round 3) and the security review (round 2) covered the same diff. This is reported on PR #35, where the reviewer can ask for another attempt once the critic is reachable.